NEW YORK — The West Sayville community is grappling with deep sorrow following a tragic domestic incident that resulted in the loss of 18-year-old Emily Finn on Tuesday morning, according to Suffolk County authorities.

Police reports indicate that officers arrived at the residence shortly after the teen’s parents contacted 911, alerting responders to an emergency situation involving two youths. Upon arrival, authorities found Emily unresponsive. She was pronounced deceased at the scene at approximately 11:10 a.m.

A 17-year-old male, identified as Emily’s former boyfriend, was discovered nearby with what investigators described as a self-inflicted gunshot wound. He was immediately transported to Stony Brook University Hospital, where he remains in critical but stable condition under medical care.

Ongoing Investigation and Expected Charges

According to the Suffolk County Police Department, the male teen is expected to face a second-degree murder charge once doctors confirm he is medically stable to appear before the court. Detectives say the investigation so far suggests Emily had gone to the home to return his belongings following a recent reported break-in.

Lieutenant Kevin Beyrer, Chief of Suffolk County Homicide, told Greater Long Island that the encounter appears to have escalated suddenly, leaving the community stunned and heartbroken.

A Promising Graduate Remembered for Her Talent and Warmth

Emily Finn graduated from Sayville High School earlier this year and was a dedicated member of the Sayville High School Music Department. Her teachers, peers, and the Sayville community describe her as a compassionate, talented young woman whose presence continually uplifted those around her.

In a heartfelt statement, the Sayville Music Boosters Association (SMBA) expressed profound grief:

“It is with the heaviest hearts that we share the loss of Emily Finn, Sayville 2025 graduate and beloved member of the Sayville HS Music Department. On behalf of SMBA, we extend our deepest condolences to her family, friends, and classmates. May we all find strength in one another during this incredibly difficult time. Emily will always be remembered for the beautiful, bright light she brought into so many lives.”

Community Support and Resources

The Sayville School District has activated support resources for students and families, including grief counselors and mental health professionals, emphasizing the importance of community care during moments of collective grief.

Authorities continue to urge anyone with additional information to contact the Suffolk County Homicide Squad as the investigation